Banned in Boston · STOP 02 · Boston Common / Downtown
H.L. Mencken came to this corner in 1926 to sell one magazine to the one man in Boston who wanted to arrest him.
On April 5, 1926, H.L. Mencken came to this corner to sell one copy of his banned magazine to the one man in Boston who wanted to arrest him. The buyer paid with a silver half dollar. The corner's nickname has nothing to do with sermons, whatever you've heard. The sidewalk where it happened is at the top of the Park Street stairs.
This is stop 2 of Banned in Boston. Walk it - any two stops are free.
The plate
Collected on site
Corner of Park Street and Tremont Street
Directions
It was staged. Chase showed up late, with Captain George W. Patterson of the vice squad, and said, per the New England Historical Society, 'I order this man's arrest.'
More footnotes on the story card, in the app.
Argue about it
Did Mencken beat Boston's censors, or did he just win a stunt?
Both sides, with their sources, are on the story card in the app.
In these collections: Legends Busted
Near Park Street · Near Downtown Crossing · Near Boylston · Near Chinatown · Near Government Center · Near State · Near Bowdoin
Sources (8)
- H.L. Mencken Arrested in Boston (April 5, 1926)Mass Moments (Massachusetts Foundation for the Humanities) · n.d. (accessed Oct 2026)
- Banned in Boston No Longer: H.L. Mencken Stands Up to the CensorsNew England Historical Society · n.d. (accessed Oct 2026)
- Banned in Boston: A Brief Tour Through 20th Century CensorshipBoston Magazine · accessed Oct 2026
- On this day in 1926: Boston, H.L. Mencken, and the landmark free-speech case that wasn'tThe Phoenix (Phlog) · 2010-04-05
- To the friends of the American Mercury: a statement (with Appendix I, Commonwealth vs. Mencken, opinion of Justice James P. Parmenter; Appendix II, The American Mercury, Inc. v. J. Frank Chase et al.)H.L. Mencken (Boston, 1926); HathiTrust catalog record 102929848 (full view, Univ. of Illinois copy) · 1926
- Park Street Church historyPark Street Church · n.d. (accessed Oct 2026)
- 41 Mount Vernon Street (building history)Boston Literary District · accessed Oct 2026
- Park Street Church, looking north, April 1, 1906 (alt. title: Tremont St.: Corner of the Common, Park St. Church to right, State House to left)Thomas E. Marr, photographer; Boston Pictorial Archive, Boston Public Library, via Digital Commonwealth · 1906-04-01