The 1852 Hunt · STOP 07 · Downtown
The Great Fire was stopped at Washington and Milk, a short distance from Old South's door.
The Great Fire of 1872 stopped just short of the Old South Meeting House, where the Tea Party meeting was held. The legend credits one engine from Portsmouth, New Hampshire. A witness at the inquiry credited wet carpets on the buildings across Washington Street, and a postmaster who three times refused to blow the church up. Go see how close it got.
This is stop 7 of The 1852 Hunt. Walk it free in the app.
The plate
Collected on site
Corner of Milk Street and Hawley Street
Directions
The commission found 'the peril from the combustion of gas was increased by the manner of using gunpowder.' One witness put it the other way round: 'We could have done better with gunpowder, if it had not been for the gas.'
More footnotes on the story card, in the app.
Argue about it
Who saved Old South: one engine from Portsmouth, or a lot of wet carpets?
Both sides, with their sources, are on the story card in the app.
In these collections: Legends Busted
Near Downtown Crossing · Near State · Near Government Center · Near Park Street · Near South Station · Near Chinatown
Sources (7)
- Great Boston Fire of 1872Boston Fire Historical Society · n.d.
- Resilience at Old South Meeting HouseRevolutionary Spaces · n.d.
- Old South Meeting HouseRevolutionary Spaces · n.d. (accessed Oct 2026)
- Report of the Commissioners appointed to investigate the cause and management of the Great Fire in BostonCity of Boston (Rockwell & Churchill) · 1873
- Looking up Milk St. to WashingtonJames Wallace Black (J. W. Black). Boston Public Library, Arts Department, Boston Pictorial Archive, via Digital Commonwealth · ca. 1872
- The Great Boston Fire of 1872Boston Public Library blog · n.d.
- Notes from the Archives: the Great Boston Fire of 1872City of Boston Archives (boston.gov) · n.d.